When I rented
The Girl Next Door, its not like I was under any false guise that it was going to be good. But, I'm still fascinated by how we (us guys, that is) put one girl on this pedestal that no female person could ever live up to. I think that The Girl Next Door very easily could have been another, albeit campy, piece in that puzzle. Unfortunately, it was Weird Science, Chasing Amy, and Risky Business, re-wrapped as this other, not-as-good movie.
First of all, the girl had, like, no lines in the entire movie. Maybe that's the point. She doesn't need lines. She's not even real. Figments of our imagination don't really need dialogue, because they are already perfect. Talking might spoil them.
Second, it doesn't really deliver on the premise of the story. Its not a terrible premise---a porn star who ended up on the wrong path actually wants to make good. So, she enlists the help of this young innocent. In my mind, a few questions should arise. Why would they like each other? What happens when the novelty wears off? What if she won't give it up to him, but screws all these other guys on tape? Why would a girl who would even consider porn as a career decide all of a sudden to stop? How would she re-connect with society? Would she end up hating the real, civilized world, and want to go back to porn immediately? What if that innocence that she finds so becoming at first, ends up being a real nuisance because he can never understand anything that she is going through. Its like when I watch a TV show that features some overweight, unattractive husband with a hot wife. Why would they get along? She's fighting anorexia, and wants to talk about it. But she can't talk to him, because its obvious that his fat ass never dealt with it! Or, she has self-esteem problems and doesn't think she's pretty. Well, fatso can't help you there either, because he dealt with the fact that he was a social misfit, incapable of ever getting laid a long time ago. Again, nothing in common. So, after the initial coolness of telling all your friends how the 'opposites attract' rule is really working for you, do you break down and realize you've got nothing to say to one another?
So the fantasy feeds itself, fooling us (again, guys, of course) into waiting for some absolute bullshit scenario like this to come along. A porn-star moving in next door. We keep getting fed all this bullshit. Movies like this, magazines like FHM or Maxim...so, guys come out with screwed up expectations. I don't want to make a commitment because that means I'll never have that three-way I've always dreamed of! Guess what, pal...if it hasn't happened already, it probably ain't gonna happen anyway. And if it does, it probably won't be nearly as great in real life as it is in your mind right now.
I think I am going to re-write The Girl Next Door. It will be about a dork that does meet up with a porn-star. Maybe they are alone in an elevator in the mall. And maybe he does grow a pair and talk to her, remembering how it worked in the movie. And maybe he does say something remotely witty (doubtful, since the only female he's had actual human contact with is probably his mother). I could write a whole movie about that split second that she actually thinks about, considers it, imagines how the situation could possibly work out. That's ninety-minutes, right there. That's right before she extinguishes the thought immediately, laughs ruefully at the kid, and leaves the elevator having already forgotten the boy that she just destroyed. Now that's a story. That's the story that should be told.
By the way, the next time I try to rent some bullshit like that, remind me that
Welcome to the Dollhouse is probably available. Or at least,
Can't Buy Me Love.